Two men serving life sentences in the 2002 Bilkis Bano gangrape and murder case have been granted bail by the Supreme Court, which has also suspended their sentences during the pendency of their appeals. The decision was taken by a bench of Justices M M Sundaresh and Prasanna B Varale, which considered their prolonged incarceration of over 17 years and the serious disability suffered by one of the applicants.
Defence cites prolonged imprisonment and disability
The convicts sought relief through advocate Siddharth Luthra, who told the court that both men had already spent more than 17 years behind bars. He further submitted that one of the applicants had not figured in the original FIR and was named as an accused nearly three years after the incident.
The defence also argued that their challenges to the 2017 Bombay High Court judgment involved questions of fact and law that were yet to be examined. Taking these submissions into consideration, the bench granted interim relief while the appeals continue.
ASG opposes suspension of sentences
Additional Solicitor General Raja Thackeray opposed the applications, arguing that the life sentences had been awarded by the trial court and upheld by the Bombay High Court after considering the evidence and the seriousness of the crimes.
The apex court nevertheless ordered suspension of the sentences and granted bail to the two applicants. It has left the task of deciding the specific bail conditions to the trial court concerned.
How the 11 convicts returned to prison
The case returned to the Supreme Court spotlight after the Gujarat Government ordered the premature release of all 11 convicts in August 2022. The remission decision was challenged before the apex court, which, on January 8, 2024, set aside the release orders and directed the convicts to surrender.
The court held that the Gujarat Government was not the appropriate authority to grant remission in the matter. Following the ruling, all 11 men were required to return to prison.
The latest decision grants bail to two of them while their appeals are being considered. Their release comes through suspension of their life sentences and does not amount to setting aside their convictions.

