Swiss chocolate company Lindt & Sprüngli has found itself at the centre of a legal controversy in the United States. In 2023, a class action lawsuit was filed against the company, accusing it of misleading consumers about the quality of its products. The case stems from allegations that Lindt’s premium dark chocolate contains significant amounts of lead and cadmium, two heavy metals known to have harmful effects on health.
The legal dispute began after a 2022 Consumer Reports study, which highlighted the presence of alarmingly high levels of lead and cadmium in Lindt’s Excellence Dark Chocolate 85% Cocoa and Excellence Dark Chocolate 70% Cocoa. The study, which examined several brands of dark chocolate, raised concerns about the long-term health effects of consuming chocolate with high metal levels. Lindt, however, was the focus of much of the backlash.
In its defence, Lindt claimed that “lead and cadmium are unavoidable in the food supply” and insisted that the trace amounts in its products were well within regulatory limits. The company further argued that marketing terms like “expertly crafted” and “finest ingredients” were simply promotional language, or “puffery,” which should not be taken as literal guarantees. This legal strategy was intended to have the case dismissed, but it only sparked further criticism.
Lindt’s argument that its marketing language was “puffery” drew widespread public ire. The term “puffery” refers to exaggerated or vague claims that no reasonable consumer would interpret as factual statements. Lindt’s legal team argued that phrases like “expertly crafted with the finest ingredients” were not intended to imply that its chocolates were free from heavy metals or other impurities.
However, this defence seemed to backfire, with critics accusing the company of undermining its credibility. Swiss newspaper NZZ am Sonntag criticised Lindt, stating that the “puffery” argument was a “self-inflicted wound” that exposed the brand’s quality claims as little more than a marketing masquerade. Social media users also voiced their disappointment, suggesting that the company had undermined its long-standing reputation for luxury and quality.
Despite the backlash, Lindt defended its stance. A company representative told AFP, “Our consumers can have full confidence” in the company’s products, reaffirming that Lindt chocolates are “expertly crafted with the finest ingredients.” However, the court rejected the motion to dismiss the case, and the lawsuit will proceed.
Consumer Reports’ Study and Broader Implications
The controversy over Lindt’s chocolate came to a head following the publication of Consumer Reports’ findings. The study revealed that Lindt’s Excellence Dark Chocolate 70% Cocoa contained 116% of the safe limit for cadmium and 48% of the safe limit for lead, while the Excellence Dark Chocolate 85% Cocoa contained 166% of the safe limit for lead and 80% for cadmium.
Though many dark chocolates contain trace amounts of heavy metals, the report underscored that regular exposure to these substances can accumulate over time, potentially leading to dangerous levels in the body. This raises the question of whether chocolate manufacturers, including Lindt, should do more to reduce these contaminants.
Consumer Reports suggested that consumers choose chocolates with lower cacao percentages, as these were found to contain fewer heavy metals. The study also warned against assuming that organic chocolate products would necessarily be safer, as some organic brands also tested positive for high levels of cadmium and lead.
For Lindt, the lawsuit and the broader concerns about heavy metals in its products could have a significant impact on its reputation. As a brand known for premium, luxury chocolates, Lindt’s claims of quality and excellence have long been a key selling point. However, the current legal challenges raise questions about the company’s transparency and commitment to consumer safety.
Despite the legal proceedings, Lindt has maintained that its products meet the highest safety standards and that the trace amounts of heavy metals in its chocolates pose no significant health risk. Yet, as the case continues, the public’s trust in Lindt’s marketing claims could be tested.